Bring your karma
Join the waitlist today
HUMBLECAT.ORG

Blind and Visually Impaired Community

Full History - 2015 - 11 - 30 - ID#3uw2vy
6
Visual art adapted for blind people: Is it appreciated? (self.Blind)
submitted 7y ago by Andreij5
Hello everyone!

I have a blindness-related question I have been asking myself for some time. I would be really curious to get the opinion of someone blind, and I really hope the question is not too naive or stupid.
I've noticed very often how in museums or in certain touristic places there are tridimensional models of something visual for blind people. For example, I saw at least two relief-representations of church-facades placed in the square in front of the church itself. In museums there are often representations of some painting, so that blind people can actually touch it (an example is $1 ). Now, maybe it's a stupid question, but I often ask myself if these things are actually appreciated by blind people or if it's a silly idea by people with sight. Maybe I got it all wrong, but I can't imagine how touching the tridimensional interpretation of the Mona Lisa could pass on an even remotely comparable sensation to the sight of the painting. I mean, it was conceived to be seen, why would it be as astonishing as something to touch? Or maybe touching it is a sufficient replacement? Or maybe touching the artwork isn't the same kind of experience, but nevertheless a different and equally satisfying experience? As I said, I would be very curious about the opinion of some people with limited sight: do you actually use those things? Are they enjoyable for you? Would you like to have them in more places or would you rather have different options provided to you?

Because altogether the whole idea seems to me like something thought by someone who knows nothing about being blind. Instead of touching a model of a church (which I imagine a bit like looking at a music sheet for someone deaf), wouldn't it be cooler to have special hours where the place is very silent and the architecture is highlighted through clever sound effects or something like that?

I look forward to your clarifications, thank you!
Lion_the_Bunny 3 points
I'm going to start with "I'm not blind, but very low vision." However, even just being very low vision, I'm a really tactile person. It drove my parents crazy - they would take me to the store as a kid and they'd have to *constantly* tell me to keep my hands to myself, stop touching things, put that down. Now that I'm an adult...I can touch whatever the FUCK I want, because I'm an adult. And I touch everything. Sometimes I touch things I don't want to - like chewed gum - because my dumb human brain wants to know what that is and my useless human eyes can't tell it. My fingers INSTANTLY knew it was chewed gum. Anyway, I've gotten off on a tangent here, the point is...touch is very important. I think it's amazing that people are doing this for others.
pxlgirl 2 points 7y ago
You see, blindness or low vision is very complex and it doesn't always mean that people see nothing at all or 100%. There is a grey area in-between. It's not possible to pinpoint it because it depends on the individual, but there are things that can be perceived by those with low vision. That being said, a visual stimuli (possibly combined with tactical input) can be even more crucial to capture the world around you.

I have very low vision myself, yet I am an artist/designer. Visuals are therefore absolutely essential, if they're done well they can make life easier for me (and even normally sighted people). I can't see shit a few feet from me, but I do see colours very well. That has saved my life many times. :)
Andreij5 [OP] 1 points 7y ago
I see, thank you very much for the insight!
If I understood you guys correctly, the experience is obviously different than actually seeing the church / artwork / whatever but stimulating and pleasant nevertheless (or maybe even more or differently pleasant?).
And I would say you guys definitely appreciate those kind of installations. All right, when that's so I'll stop questioning their usefulness! Thanks again!
[deleted] 1 points 7y ago
[deleted]
This nonprofit website is run by volunteers.
Please contribute if you can. Thank you!
Our mission is to provide everyone with access to large-
scale community websites for the good of humanity.
Without ads, without tracking, without greed.
©2023 HumbleCat Inc   •   HumbleCat is a 501(c)3 nonprofit based in Michigan, USA.