Bring your karma
Join the waitlist today
HUMBLECAT.ORG

Blind and Visually Impaired Community

Full History - 2017 - 05 - 21 - ID#6cez5l
17
The BBC blew it tonight (self.Blind)
submitted by awesomesaucesaywhat

The BBC blew it, big time.
Last week when the Doctor went blind I cringed, hard, because I knew they could either make this an awesome thing and take the opportunity to tactfully educate people, or they could treat it as a liability, a drawback, a weakness.

I was so hoping they would show the doctor with a white cane, even if just for a bit until he somehow fixes his sight. Instead, he is navigating fine with these special glasses that show him a FAINT GREEN OUTLINE about where walls and doors are. An outline so faint I (legally blind but still fairly sighted) can barely tell what it is supposed to be when my face is literally touching my 36 inch monitor. And the text on his magic glasses, I have no clue what they are supposed to be telling him. His character is supposedly blind enough to not notice the guy in front of him is wearing white papal robes, but he can see a faint green line.

When he is trying to read the mysterious Veritas book on the laptop and his vision is getting worse from his attempt to fix it I was so hopeful the BBC would show the amazing capabilities most computers have built-in, namely a screen-reader. He could have magnified the screen, he could have had the computer read it to him, he even could have used a braille display (because the doctor knows everything anyway). And when he does get the computer to read it to him all he says is “there’s a thing on here, it reads to you, it’s very useful.” The doctor highlights human ingenuity all the time, but instead of mentioning text to speech by name and addressing the amazing things technology can help blind people achieve the whole situation is blown off. That “thing” on the computer is a huge part of life for blind and visually impaired people. It enables us to read, to code computers, to communicate, to do almost everything a sighted person can do on a computer, but it was blown off. Just a “thing.”

Yes, I know, the doctor’s enemies can’t know he’s blind. And clearly the BBC didn’t set out to portray the doctor as a blind man, but can you imagine how meaningful it would be for the doctor to be blind and still kickass? It doesn’t matter how long he is blind for, even if it were just a single episode they had the chance to portray blind people in a positive light, instead of ignoring his vision problems until they create a problem.

For him to use the white cane would have been revolutionary. Doctor Who has a huge fanbase and they had a chance to show that blindness isn’t a weakness. They didn’t need to make it a kitchy-PSA, but they also didn’t need to treat it the way they did. This was a once in a lifetime chance for the BBC and Doctor Who, and they blew it. I said when I started losing my vision that I wouldn’t become an angry person. I said I wouldn’t become one of those people who become an internet-vigilante, that are angry about every portrayal if their disability/circumstances, but I am seriously upset by this.

I really hope next episode someone tells him that he can still “save them” even though he is blind. I would love to see the doctor have to mourn his vision loss and accept the changes before realizing it doesn’t have to limit him. I still love doctor who, and I finished the episode, and I will watch the next episode, but I am amazingly disappointed by BBC right now and I needed to vent.
fastfinge 5 points 6y ago
At the risk of coming off as a negative, angry fanboy, I really wasn't expecting much better. The writing for the entire show over the last two seasons has really been an overall letdown.
awesomesaucesaywhat [OP] 6 points 6y ago
True. I had no idea I would react the way I did to the episode. It just really angered me, like out of the blue.
HailDaHailu 1 points 6y ago
While I understand your argument, and to be honest naively thinking the blind community would like these episodes... I theorise that this won't be the end of the Doctor's blindness.

Why, you may ask? One example is that there is precedence for the Doctor trying to get his sight back, and it going horribly wrong. In the Veritas episode, as you mentioned, he tries to get his sight back - in order to read the otherwise inaccessible paper-based diary, and not the computer (at least that was my impression, anyway) - And this goes wrong because the very same monks as in 'Pyramid' appear to attack him. I thought the the fact he had to blow out the candle and kill the lights so that they were -all- blind in a sense, was his way of accepting that he was much better at being blind than they were, and could use this to escape (Same thing was done in the young adult short story She Is Not Invisible but that's a different story)
TL;DR - The doctor realises once that when he tries to regain his sight, it fails. Why should this time be any different?

The second point is that we must not forget it was the Monks restored his sight. Yes, they could sense that Bill asked them to out of love, and not out of fear, nor out of strategy - like the other soldiers (though an argument could be made for it being a mix of all three). However there is a reason they want love to consent - through love, the consentor doesn't want to resist. Notice that the Monks definitely do not have the doctor's best interest at heart. As the episode closes, they whisper something along the lines of 'You have your sight back, Doctor. Now watch the end of the world' - paraphrase - which I think betrays their true motives.


robsug 3 points 6y ago
Personally I thought it was a bit of a cop out that he had the glasses. He wasn't blind with them. It would have been more interesting to see him interact and problem solve as a blind Doctor. It would have been empowering for blind or partially sighted people to know he can still succeed just as well without his sight.
Instead what we got was that he couldn't cope or even function being blind and had to resort to bargaining with his future self to receive his sight back.
A real opportunity missed.
awesomesaucesaywhat [OP] 1 points 6y ago
That is exactly how I feel
rkingett 2 points 6y ago
I wish this show were still on USA Netflix. drat!
awesomesaucesaywhat [OP] 2 points 6y ago
I use the BBC America app. I log in with the email and the tv provider and then I can watch the shows.
HailDaHailu 1 points 6y ago
Hi awesomesauce. Sorry for waiting a month to say this and all - but if you're still watching Doctor Who you and mostly u/ScottSaw were absolutely right - they didn't keep the Doctor being blind and if was as if it was just a plot point.

You should have been gilded, not me.
ScottSaw 2 points 6y ago
🤞 Chibnall makes the next doctor blind to properly explore this, he said he was going to take the franchise in a new direction.
awesomesaucesaywhat [OP] 2 points 6y ago
Haha thanks, but don't worry about it! I'm still a little blown away that it was literally only a two episode plot point and never mentioned again. Also, so torn up about the cyber man thing and I have conflicting feelings on missy. I'm honestly not sure if I'll watch the next season with a new doctor :/
HailDaHailu 1 points 6y ago
>Also, so torn up about the cyber man thing

Totally - I wasn't expecting them to be in 'World Enough and Time'.

When they were putting the side-helmet thingy on Bill that was so scary...

Actually, I though the suits were more like the ones in 'Oxygen'... and I may have another theory coming on... that the suits in Oxygen and the cybermen *could be the same thing*. I thought the suits footsteps sound like those in Oxygen... am I right, or are there some differences?

> conflicting feelings on missy.

Yeah exactly- at first I though she was good, then I thought she was evil pretending to be good, then the moment when you think she's joined the Doctor she kind of 'flirts' with the Russian guy Bill was with...

>I'm honestly not sure if I'll watch the next season with a new doctor :/

Yeah, Peter Capaldi has *become* the personification of the Doctor for me now. I did like David Tenant but I'm not sure they could go to someone like that again. They would need to be even more serious, still with a fun side....

Maybe, at long last, we could have a female doctor?
HailDaHailu 1 points 6y ago
> or they could treat it as a liability, a drawback, a weakness.

I think this is only how The Doctor is treating his blindness at some points. He doesn't want to tell Bill, because he doesn't want 'to make it real', but I was so glad he told Nardole because he can't hide it forever, and there's no reason why he should. But he is.

Remember he only became blind a few episodes ago. Those who weren't born blind (ie u/Nighthawk321, though you don't need to answer this, Nighthawk, by any means) - what was it like in the first few days? Did you have moments of weakness or doubting yourself before you realised 'stuff hating my disability, I'm going to accept it and get on with my life'? Well, I think that's what the Doctor's going through. (Myself having not experienced this being born mildly visually impaired, I can't imagine what it must be like being able to do something like seeing or walking, and then just - not. So that's why I ask other redditors.)

And I think he was at the end of that process by only two episodes, which IHMO shows the Doctor's strength. Knowing that disguising his blindness is something he wants to do, not anyone else's choice, he was finally trying to tell Bill at two points in this week's episode - yet both times the Monks stopped him indirectly. He disguises asking for help in the lab 'Hello?' by saying 'I'm the Doctor. Saving the world with my eyes shut.' which I thought was a great line but hey, it may be corny for some.

He doesn't accept it fully himself, and -this- is why he gets into trouble by 'The Pyramid at End of World.' Because he hasn't told anyone, the 'secret' of his blindness is 'leaked out at the one time he most need people to help him. (Yes, they could've may it different rather than a simple combination lock stopping the Doctor- but let's keep with that idea for now) Bill, who remember, has been led to believe that the Doctor's blindness has been 'cured', has just been hit with the news that - it isn't. Given that she's just discovered the Doctor is blind, she believes she's doing the best for him. She goes to the Monks, pleading with them to save the Doctor's sight, thinking this will help. Will it? Maybe.




What do you think? I know I'm coming from a weird perspective, not being fully blind and all... but I've been thinking about this too.

Side note: in which case, how would you guys write a blind Doctor? Or a blind 'hero'?
alishainc 1 points 6y ago
It's disappointing that they had an oppurntitu to speak on and share tips on computer accessibility and didn't
This nonprofit website is run by volunteers.
Please contribute if you can. Thank you!
Our mission is to provide everyone with access to large-
scale community websites for the good of humanity.
Without ads, without tracking, without greed.
©2023 HumbleCat Inc   •   HumbleCat is a 501(c)3 nonprofit based in Michigan, USA.