I'd like to hear some descriptions of how blind people experience dreaming(self.Blind)
submitted by Cephalie
I realize it seems like a stupid question, but in my experience my dreams are more visually-driven than my day-to-day life so I wanted to ask. I'm starting to work on a fantasy novel in which the magic centers around dreams and one of my characters is blind.
I'd especially like to hear about nightmares with monsters or other creatures. But any details would be fantastic even if it seems sort of mundane.
Thanks very much for your time!
Hannabis805 points5y ago
There's a blind youtuber Tommy Edison he's made a video about being blind and dreaming, plus he's made some other pretty good informative videos, they might be able to help in some way.
I'm not completely blind, but I am night blind. Lots of my nightmares revolve around me being a passenger in a car without much sight, just glare from the headlights. The fear stems from the feeling, the sensation of movement is very strong for me, falling, speeding, starts and quick turns are very clear. The driver sometimes disappears, and I've never driven, so that's terrifying. Sometimes they just become distracted and I can sense them veering. I don't know how many sighted people dream about monsters, so I'm not sure how many blind people will have insight about that either. I don't smell things, but I do hear voices and feel the wind and stuff of that nature. Dreams that have a daytime setting have a varying amount of visual feedback. I don't see very much, faces I've seen in magnified photos are the most common. A rule of thumb is that if a person has ever had sight, they might have visual dreams, but if they haven't, they won't.
ilivetofly5 points5y ago
I will add (I am not someone with blindness or sight issues) that people who have always been totally blind can get visual esque feedback depending on the nature of their blindness. Often it's just vague moving patterns or such that crop up rarely as your body learns to ignore the pointless eyes but those experiences can come across in dreams.
Ofc such a person would probably be unable to distinguish what they are dreaming about is something that is visual in nature but it's worth considering.
Practically though, if you don't know it's visual and have no way to describe it or distinguish then is it really visual?
That specific brain fart aside motion based nightmares are basically the fucking worst imo I can't imagine dreaming dreams like you described. I probably would just bail on sleep all together.
Cephalie [OP]3 points5y ago
I had absolutely no idea about that. Really interesting but if you believe that dreams are your brains way of getting you to think about and prepare for a lot of crazy scenarios it makes sense that it would still throw visual information at you after going blind.
Cephalie [OP]1 points5y ago
Thanks a lot for replying, I can begin to imagine what a dream with those sensations would be like it must be so intense!
>I don't know how many sighted people dream about monsters, so I'm not sure how many blind people will have insight about that either.
I do fairly often because I read/watch a lot of horror and fantasy. But I realize it's a part of the question that isn't at all applicable to a lot of people.
>A rule of thumb is that if a person has ever had sight, they might have visual dreams, but if they haven't, they won't.
This is true even if sight was lost at a very young age?
Derpette42203 points5y ago
Based on what I've learned from other blinder people, you forget your sight after a while of complete blindness. Very few blind people are completely blind, though.
I suppose you could write a character who lost their sight in an accident in recent memory, that would be the most logical way to write it, I think.
coolbreeze19903 points5y ago
On a related note. My father is blind and here is one of my favorite stories from him.
He dropped acid one time. Just once. He took at and discovered himself in a great hall. I’m talking infinitely large. With an infinitely large table running down the middle. (How he knew how big the room and table were?- great question and I never thought of it until now. I’ll ask him soon.).
He heard the great booming voice of what he knew to be an angel. The angel said something like “don’t you ever do this again” and *snap* just like that he wasn’t tripping anymore.
More of a cool tripping story than a cool blind story I reckon.
coolbreeze19902 points5y ago
To better answer the dreaming question. I’ve asked him many times what that’s like and he said it’s more about voices and physical sensations for him. Just like life I guess. He’s really into voices. That’s how he determines the relative ‘attractiveness’ of a woman is by her voice.
coolbreeze19902 points5y ago
Oh I should note. He’s always been completely blind. Well some light perception. Except for a 6week period in his 30s when he had some scar tissue removed from his retinas and he could see colors and shapes. Said he couldn’t tell the difference between a tree and a light pole to give you some idea. Then he woke up one day and it was gone.
I believe the acid trip was before this surgery.
Broken_seeker2 points5y ago
This can differ depending on the sitation a person is in. A person who has been blind from birth will dream completely differently than someone who had sight and later lost it.
I'm the latter category. My dreams are very much still fully visual for the most part. I lost my sight only about ten years ago. They have always been completely vivid and too real. In fact after I lost my sight I was having confusing dreams of waking up with my sight again and my dreaming mind wourd rationalize that I was blind only part of the time, not realizing dreams weren't real.
I had sight in only one eye all my life, my sight in one was lost when I was still a baby so mydreams reflect that even today.
I have had some incredibly vivid nightmares including one where I was killed by being hit by a car and the dream continued aftert he fact where I saw my own body. Otherwise my nightmares are pretty run of the mill, being chased by things, ones where someone is trying to do unsolicitied things to me, the like.
In the end it really depends on if your character was blind all their life, or lost it later on that really determines how they'll dream.
[deleted]2 points5y ago
I have acquired blindness and I love dreams because I see faces of family members as I remember them. They are detailed and focused. One good thing is that I think of them looking forever younger, even though they look like ghosty blobs now.
Also all my memories of nature like grass, trees, clouds, stars are still crystal clear in dreams.
razzretina1 points5y ago
I’m legally blind (acuity of less than 20/800 in the working eye; it’s bad enough that they can’t measure what I see ha ha). My dreams are very colorful but the focus is much more on feeling and sensation. They’re kind of frantic and jump around a lot, but usually in a somewhat linear way (well, I understand how it goes from shopping with my dead ex mother in law to being a lovesick fictional character who’s been kidnapped). I do have extremely vivid nightmares (good ol PTSD) but there aren’t usually many monsters around. There’s a lot of blood, viscera, and enclosed spaces though. Mostly it’s a feeling of dread, a presence that’s chasing me deeper into a terrible place I don’t want to be. Sometimes it’s just one nightmare element in an otherwise mundane dream (the blood pit full of teeth just hanging out in a school floor; everyone called it Steve and it was apparently friendly as long as you didn’t fall into it). And once in a great while I’ll have a sleep paralysis dream that ends with something screaming and leaping out at me from the side right before I wake up unable to move. I’ve had a few dreams wherevi “woke up” into another dream, usually with things feeling progressively worse as they went on. I’m happy to tell you more if you’re interested/it might help with your story.
Our mission is to provide everyone with access to large- scale community websites for the good of humanity. Without ads, without tracking, without greed.