I'm curious about your relationship with various media(self.Blind)
submitted by DeleteriousEuphuism
What do you think of audio in movies? Does it bother you when a sound doesn't match the audio description of a scene?
Do you have a preference between audio books and braille books? Are there books that appeal more to you by placing more emphasis on non-visual descriptions? Are blind authors better at writing books for you?
Is there a medium dedicated to audio narratives? Here I don't mean movies with audio descriptions nor audio books which are narrations of books, but I mean a medium which uses audio in the same way that movies use video. I'll try to clarify if you have further questions about what I mean here.
KillerLag3 points5y ago
Oftentimes, the audio description doesn't match up to the sound because that sound would impede hearing the description. For example, in one of the Batman movies, the audio description was something like "Batman punches a goon" or "Batman pries open the door with a concealed device in his hand". The exact moment that scene occurs is usually quite noisy, and would be difficult to hear the description.
Almost everyone I know uses audio books for any extended period of reading. Keep in mind that Braille cells have to be a certain size, so books end up becoming quite large. For example, this is roughly what the Bible looks like in Braille.
Conversely, an audio file on an iPhone has virtually no weight, and you can hold a great number of them on your phone. It is significantly easier to pull out your phone and headphones to listen to something, rather than carry a phone book sized book.
DeleteriousEuphuism [OP]2 points5y ago
Thanks for putting the size difference of braille into context for me. It certainly puts into perspective how much the advent of new technologies can help.
derrekjthompson1 points5y ago
This is easily solved nowadays though with E-books where you can read the book on a braille display. I'd say my consumption of books is about half audio books and half braille. Even before E-books I still read plenty of novels in braille, despite the size.
ENTJ3512 points4y ago
So, I will answer one of them, you got good answers for the others and I don’t use those often. I don’t watch movies with audio descriptions, I either watch them without or not at all. And I don’t listen to audio that much.
I would say my preferred medium is braille but by a braille display. I don’t read audio books wel. I don’t tend to pay attention to the details there. I just gloss over and listen for the main ideas. So if I really want to do that book any justice I read it.
Yeah, a braille book can be large. My favorite comparison is of the bible. Go look at one, I don’t care if you are not religious. You know what a regular bible looks like right? Well a braillebible takes up three shelves of a bookshelf or three levels. So, it’s huge. Imagine 20 books of a size of a family picture album. That’s a bible for us. Quite portable no? Wouldn’t you just love to carry one of those bibles to church with you?
derrekjthompson2 points5y ago
The answer already given to your other question about audio description in movies is correct so I won't rehash it. As far as a medium devoted to audio narratives, it exists. It's called audio drama or radio drama, I like it myself and I know it has some blind fans. As far as visual descriptions in books, yes if the author is going on and on about the colors of things it can turn me off. However as someone who was born completely blind I think visual descriptions in books have also helped me understand things from the sighted person's perspective.
DeleteriousEuphuism [OP]1 points5y ago
I never knew about audio dramas. It seems like a medium with a lot of potential considering how every one and their grandma has a podcast nowadays.
Our mission is to provide everyone with access to large- scale community websites for the good of humanity. Without ads, without tracking, without greed.