Bring your karma
Join the waitlist today
HUMBLECAT.ORG

Blind and Visually Impaired Community

Full History - 2018 - 12 - 11 - ID#a5coap
13
Is Amazon's Alexa useful in practice for the blind? (self.Blind)
submitted by questioner2233
I have an elderly recently blind relative. I am considering installing Alexa.

Does anyone know if this is a good or bad idea? The idea of him being able to say, Alexa, play radio, is good. But is the system really that good in practice?

There are always complications with these things. I appreciate any help. Thanks
ZippyTWP 8 points 4y ago
Google voice has a bit more utility, in my opinion, and better voice recognition. But I do get a lot of milage out of voice command stuff.
DYMongoose 5 points 4y ago
I got one for my mom last Christmas and it's one of her favorite things. She listens to the radio, searches for recipes, listens to the news, and gets answers to basic questions in the same fashion that I would use Google. She's also got a lamp with a smart plug so she can ask Alexa if the lamp is on or off, and change that if desired. (She's not the only one in the house)
questioner2233 [OP] 1 points 4y ago
thanks that sounds cool. Which model out of interest? looks like there's a "dot" and a normal one?
enzwificritic 2 points 4y ago
The Echo has speakers suitable for listening to music on, while the Echo Dot has a speaker that is only good enough for the commands and alarms. If you want to listen to music with the Dot, you'll want to connect speakers to it.
DYMongoose 1 points 4y ago
I got her the dot because it was cheaper and I didn't know how it would turn out. The normal one has identical functionality, but a better speaker for richer sound quality.

I will add: this wasn't something that she could set up herself. It requires a smartphone/tablet to get started, and to enable "skills" (functionality). Google Home is the same way at first, but there are no skills to enable. Once it's set up, it's good to go.
Laser_Lens_4 4 points 4y ago
Alexa is pretty competent. No huge complaints there. If they use Google services then you would be better off getting a Google home. It has access to more free streaming services and has slightly better voice recognition and voice synthesis.
lightsrage85 2 points 4y ago
Are use my Echo Dot all the time, I have two of them, one in my living room, and one in my bedroom. I could hook a set of speakers into the one in the living room. I use my Echo Dot for just about everything I want to go. I also have a fire stick hooked up to my TV that is Alexa enabled are use my fire stick for tasks like listening to audio and watching prime movies so that is helpful my echo at all the pets other accessories help me on a daily basis I think your relative would like it there or even thermostats that work with the echo there are lights there are plugs that you can plug all kinds of things into there are even the new microwave from Amazon a plethora liked overjoyed that was sent items and I believe the echo was the first smart speaker on the market oh and now the echo has Apple Music
questioner2233 [OP] 2 points 4y ago
great thanks. I got an Echo in the end. It is awesome. Best thing is linking in a phone, so my relative can make phone calls - and receive them too, linking up with skype. thanks
lightsrage85 1 points 4y ago
I am so glad I could help, it’s always good when people enjoy what they get. I am in a nursing home now, but my husband is mailing me one of the echo dots we have at home so I can use it here. It will make things so much easier.
questioner2233 [OP] 1 points 4y ago
thank you, and best wishes from the UK.
[deleted] 2 points 4y ago
[deleted]
questioner2233 [OP] 1 points 4y ago
thanks that sounds cool. Which model out of interest? looks like there's a "dot" and a normal one?
yourmommaisaunicorn 2 points 4y ago
It does more than just the radio. It can tell you the news (typically plays the opening bit of The Daily Show, CNN, and NPR news for me), make calls if you have it connected to your phone, plays any music on Amazon Music, and can add stuff to your cart.

I mainly use it for music while I’m cleaning, tell dad jokes (“Alexa tell me a joke”), and trivia as the Alexa marketplace has a fun daily trivia game you can play.
questioner2233 [OP] 1 points 4y ago
thanks that sounds cool. Which model out of interest? looks like there's a "dot" and a normal one?
yourmommaisaunicorn 1 points 4y ago
My understanding is they both do the same thing, the dot just has smaller speakers.
tasareinspace 1 points 4y ago
absolutely.

​

Right now, my daughter (the visually impaired person in our house) uses the echo dot to set her alarms, ask about the weather, listen to her jams (I mean it's not the best speaker but she is 11 so not very picky), turn her lights on and off, etc. We've been thinking about getting her a spot or a show next year, because she'll be coming home on her own and I want to be able to check in on her and see her face. I can also see this being useful with an elderly relative.

​

(it doesn't just immediately show the room when you drop in on it, it makes a loud chiming noise so you can decline the call, and fades in from being fuzzy after a few seconds)
questioner2233 [OP] 1 points 4y ago
Wait, turn lights on and off, how does that work?

Also "spot" or "show" - is that a phone product?

This is so useful thanks.
tasareinspace 1 points 4y ago
You can connect the echo to Phillips Hue lights (and I think a few other brands of lights) which are wi-fi enabled lights.

​

The echo comes in the regular echo, the echo plus, and the echo dot, which are all pure audio devices, you talk to it, and it talks back. The Echo Spot and the Echo Show both have screens and cameras, so you can use video chatting on them (as well as it displaying pictures, video, weather, etc)
matt_may 1 points 4y ago
I’m VIP and I find it helpful. Weather, news, streams radio, my kindle books, etc.
questioner2233 [OP] 1 points 4y ago
thanks
amusingbush23 1 points 4y ago
Yes!!! My mom uses hers every day. I would recommend it but be mindful you have to download the app first (on a smartphone or tablet) to get it all setup. After that it’s a breeze. She even orders stuff herself through amazon.
ControllerD 1 points 4y ago
Yes, my wife and her friend, both totally blind, use Alexa frequently. We do have some Echo Dots, one on the kitchen and one in our bedroom. The bedroom one she uses for alarms, and also to find out the weather to help decide what clothes to wear. The kitchen one she uses for both music whilst cooking, and also multiple named alarms to help her when cooking/baking. We also have an Echo (not dot) in the living room. I would say that the Echo is much better at hearing her, the speaker is massively better, and when using as a phone, (both my wife and her friend talk to each other through it), the Echo has a clear advantage with the microphone. That said, the Dot is good enough to start with - does all the same things.
questioner2233 [OP] 1 points 4y ago
that's fantastic, thank you, and sounds like a very nice home set up, thanks.
ControllerD 1 points 4y ago
No problem. Yes, it’s taken a while to get used to but it works well. As I’m sure you have experience of, I’m always on the look out for small things to make her life easier. Best of luck with it for you.
BlackKingBarTender 1 points 4y ago
There’s supposedly a sousvide that’s controlled entirely by Alexa. I’ve never used a sous vide but that might be a big deal.
This nonprofit website is run by volunteers.
Please contribute if you can. Thank you!
Our mission is to provide everyone with access to large-
scale community websites for the good of humanity.
Without ads, without tracking, without greed.
©2023 HumbleCat Inc   •   HumbleCat is a 501(c)3 nonprofit based in Michigan, USA.