Can blind people be exempted from jury duty in the U.S.?(self.Blind)
submitted by TheBlindBookLover
Jury duty is something that many of us dread. I am not entirely opposed to using my blindness to get out of this commitment if called upon. What has been your experience when contacted?
ENTJ3517 points4y ago
I just don’t really condone using the blind card here. It seems really unnecessary and a wrong way to do it. It also gives blind people a bad reputation.
TheBlindBookLover [OP]2 points4y ago
Hi. Thanks for responding. I have never been called for jury duty. I also just want to make it clear that I was joking about using blindness to get out of jury duty. I totally understand how doing so would create further misconceptions. I was curious if someone has done this and if anyone had stories as a blind person on a jury.
ENTJ3511 points4y ago
Yeah, lots of people tend to do this on a more serious note so sorry.
I have been sent a letter but never actually been called or needed. But I think it’d be interesting really.
preiman7903 points4y ago
It’s not too difficult to get a doctor to write you something for a medical exemption, but if you do go down what is going to happen is there going to have you sit around for most of the day they’re going to call you in every now and then to ask you a few questions and then will dismiss you because nobody wants a blind juror. Depending on your state and city you may have to do this for a couple of days in a row.
That_Dog_Nextdoor2 points4y ago
There was a blind judge who said he could do his job better because of less biased. Like being able to look a guy straight in the eye and say not judge on tattoos.
preiman7901 points4y ago
I believe it, I never said a blind person couldn’t be a good juror I said that most lawyers will instantly dismiss a blind juror
That_Dog_Nextdoor2 points4y ago
Only when like videos are part of the evidence or their clients innocent look/the othe rparties bad look is part of their strategy
preiman7902 points4y ago
Not in my experience. In my experience anything that makes it even possible that you’re going to be harder to convince or have to be convinced differently is enough. And for a lot of people the idea of having to present evidence to a blind juror is enough to want to dismiss that juror. I’m not talking about what is or isn’t reasonable just what my experience and the experience of the people I’ve spoken to has been.
gracefulltree2 points4y ago
I would be proud to serve on a jury! It’s one of my rights as a citizen and I wouldn’t think of using my disability to get out of it. (My left-wing social worker politics, on the other hand... /s)
In all seriousness, I’ve been called, and I got as far as the room where we watch the video on being a responsible juror, then they decided they didn’t actually need jurors that day and sent us home. (The video did not have descriptions, nor did they have large print for me. Didn’t ask about Braille b/c I can’t read it and have some usable vision.)
Also, isn’t justice *supposed* to be blind?
Marconius1 points4y ago
I was summoned to jury duty a few weeks after going totally blind. I had my doctor draft a letter appended to the response form saying that I would no longer be able to serve and that the blindness was permanent. This has kept me off the summoning list entirely. I'd just be frustrated trying to ingest as much information as I could if I were to be called today, as I was hyper-visual and feel that I would personally be a much better juror if I was still able to see. It's not something I'm interested in doing now, hence the permanent relief letter.
bigblindmax1 points4y ago
Yes, I managed it a few years ago on the basis that I couldn’t get reliable transportation to and from court (it was a federal court like an hour away). I didn’t even need a doctors note IIRC.
Edit: that said, going to court isn’t that dreadworthy. They’re pretty accessible and people can help you out with navigation, if needed. You will either be accommodated or left off the jury, so don’t worry about it.
glitterrayne1 points4y ago
When I lived in California I got summonsed to jury duty. I went with my white cane and when they saw I was blind I filled out some paperwork (well they helped me do so) and submitted something from my doctor stating I was legally blind and was exempted from all jury duty.
It was not that I didn't want to do it but many jurys are very visual in nature. Being able to see the case exibits etc is kind of important.
OutWestTexas1 points4y ago
I have been called for jury duty three times but never picked because I work for the police department. I would have loved to do it.
bscross321 points4y ago
I would get the exemption. I can't see how they would take a blind person anyway, since so much of evidence is visual, and so much of the world is visual. What you hear, smell and the like carry so much less weight than what you see.
Our mission is to provide everyone with access to large- scale community websites for the good of humanity. Without ads, without tracking, without greed.