Hi there. I'm battling a vision loss condition right now and am trying to acclimate myself to assistive technology that will assist me when I periodically lose my vision (as well as if/when that loss becomes more permanent).
Can anyone recommend the best/most natural sounding screen reader? I am currently completing a research degree and have to do a lot of reading and note taking. I'd really like something that makes the process of listening to written text as pleasant as possible.
Thank you so much!
(edit: to provide more information, I use a Windows desktop PC and primarily read via web browser or, importantly, PDFs :))
Laser_Lens_43 points3y ago
That depends on several factors. First off, which operating system are you most comfortable with? Windows has a few options; the two most popular are JAWS and NVDA. Mac OS has Voiceover built in. NVDA is free while JAWS is quite expensive. Do you prefer a tactile interface? If so then an iPad or iPhone is best suited for a sight-free workflow. Talkback for Android is an option, though it can be frustrating without any usable vision.
​
It sounds like your main focus is on the TTS (text-to-speech) component of the screen reader. That is entirely up to personal preference. Apple features the most natural voices out of the box on their screen readers. JAWS ships with Vocalizer Expressive, which is based on DECtalk. NVDA taps into the Windows core voices, but you can use eSpeak if you really want. It's extremely robotic, but some users get more benefit out of it at very high speed. There are a number of aftermarket voices available for the Windows screen readers. Apple gives you a selection of voices to choose from, and you better like them because it's all you'll get. Talkback taps into whatever TTS engine is installed on an Android phone. Usually it's Google TTS which is on the harsh side but quite good. You can install new ones from Google Play, if you wish. When on Voiceover, I use a mix of voices depending on what I'm doing. When I'm on Windows, I usually use Microsoft Mark. As for Talkback, I prefer Google TTS English UK female.
​
How far are you in learning a screen reader? If you need something right now, Smartphones are the easiest to learn and master. If you have a Mac and are good with computers in general, it will take you maybe 2 or 3 days to get used to the basics with the built-in tutorial. JAWS and NVDA have steeper learning curves, but they've given me the most versatility. If you need it, I can give you basic tutorials for all of them.
CloudyBeep2 points3y ago
Vocalizer Expressive voices aren't based on DecTalk—they're natural-sounding. Eloquence, the default synthesizer, isn't based on DecTalk either, even though they both use similar methods to generate text-to-speech.
Laser_Lens_42 points3y ago
Thanks for letting me know. Guess I got those mixed up. My bad
bjayernaeiy1 points3y ago
NVDA also has vocalizer voices, and aditionally you can use the eloquence TTS same as JAWS. Good breakdown though!
oncenightvaler1 points3y ago
VoiceOver for Mac in my opinion, + its built in and integrated into the Operating System software.
I've used Narrator and Jaws and even tried ZoomText and I like VoiceOver best.
guitarandbooks1 points3y ago
When I am running Windows 10, I usually use Jaws from Freedom Scientific, which I've been using since college. I now use NVDA at least some of the time and it is really starting to become a contender. I use voiceover on my Mac, iPhone, and iPad.
I lost my sight when I was in middle school so had to relearn the computer from scratch without sight. It was difficult but over time, I got used to it. The hardest part for me was no longer having visual orientation.
I didn't actually use windows much until I started college. I had a macintosh IIsi in high school with the screen reader called Outspoken. Do any of you remember that? This was in the mid to late 1990s...
warm_and_buzzy1 points3y ago
Does anyone use the Chromevox plugin for Chrome? Or is it so bad that it's not worth the install?
Prefect3162 points3y ago
If you're on Windows it's not even worth it. Jaws can do everything with no issue. Not sure about NVDA though.
I do use Chromevox on Chrome for my Mac, though, as VO and Google Docs do not seem to play nice.
astrolurus1 points3y ago
JAWS and NVDA are standard. Jaws is free to try rn and NVDA is always free.
I’d recommend ZoomText if you have low vision- you can use it to read text and the edge smoothing is much better than the built in windows magnifier.
Once the world has opened back up again, you might find assistive technology training useful- your trainer can help teach you how to use screenreaders most efficiently and how to use shortcuts etc.
YashSonkiya1 points3y ago
I use JAWS and it works fine for me.
note\* i use a crack version
SLJ72 points3y ago
We're getting free JAWS for the next almost 2 months so there has never been a better time to test it.
YashSonkiya2 points3y ago
in that case, you should try it. but do note that you have to remember the keystrokes so that you can use JAWS efficiently. and their are many keystrokes, some for genral use and some for app specific use.
bjayernaeiy1 points3y ago
What do you mean, has Freedom Scientific made JAWS free or do you just use the blindhelp version?
andi12351 points3y ago
I believe they're making it free for two months.
bradley221 points3y ago
That’s if you live in america.
Drop9Reddit1 points3y ago
I would also factor in what applications you need to use what screen reader works beat with those.
spacewalking-1 points3y ago
For just article/news reading from a webpage, $1 has in my opinion the most natural sounding voice and it cleans up ads and other unnecessary artifacts from the page. you can use the chrome extension to read directly from chrome and Microsoft edge as well . Disclaimer I'm the creator of Hewizo
Our mission is to provide everyone with access to large- scale community websites for the good of humanity. Without ads, without tracking, without greed.