Thoughts on Audio Description Availability(self.Blind)
submitted by [deleted]
[deleted]
oncenightvaler2 points3y ago
Here's a story of irony: There's a show called "In The Dark" about a blind woman and her friends, and it's a soap/crime drama because she is solving the murder of a good friend. It lacked audio description.
I find the streaming services are better than Cable at consistently having audio description.
CloudyBeep1 points3y ago
Are you sure? The CW promised to include it before the show aired, and have done so.
oncenightvaler2 points3y ago
not on my cable as far as I know????? I've tried it a few times and could not find it.
Blindman2k171 points3y ago
I think it’s a local affiliate issue mine here in Kentucky does not do so either.
CloudyBeep1 points3y ago
But you're in Canada I think, so that's up to whatever network broadcasts it there. I was talking about the US since it's a US show. But it's strange that you don't have it since Canada requires most primetime shows to have AD.
[deleted] [OP]2 points3y ago
[deleted]
OtterlyFoxed2 points3y ago
I can certainly understand the problems arising when trying to audio describe reality and sports content. So I guess what you are saying is that certain broadcasters such as the BBC far out perform others. Perhaps Sony Television and Warner Bros Television could look to the BBC as a standard.
[deleted] [OP]1 points3y ago
[deleted]
Blindman2k171 points3y ago
I think it could be a lot better plus the fact you can’t use it with new technology such as Dolby Atmos I think it’s a disgrace. Why do we have to be left out on the one thing that makes a huge difference for us sound?
SightlessBastard1 points3y ago
I think, when it comes to The availability off audio description, the biggest obstacle is, and always was, the different laws of the different countries. I am living in Germany. We have no audio description for foreign shows at all. That’s why I watch almost everything in English nowadays. We also don’t have access to audio described content from the UK or the US. At least not without a VPN. LOL. For example. Channel 4 in the UK, recently added the show Buffy the Vampire Slayer. They are still in the middle of adding description to that. There is no way, we would ever have that in my country. Neither in English nor translate it. Yes, Netflix does a very good job with describing their content. But they can’t do everything. That’s why I’m glad, that websites like audiovault.net exist. I have a Netflix subscription. But, well, not everything, I would like to watch, is on Netflix.
coarsing_batch1 points3y ago
I’m sorry… Did you just say that Buffy is being described? We need to find this immediately! I watch that when it aired back in the late 90s. What an awesome show. I need that in my world. I hope they finish it all soon.
SightlessBastard2 points3y ago
Yup, it is in the on-demand section on the channel for website. So far, the first season is available described completely, and the first three episodes of season two are described as well. I know, that the guys from audiovault.net are already taking care of it. I am doing my own recordings, since I plan to add the described track to my DVDs.
coarsing_batch1 points3y ago
Oh its a diy situation?
SightlessBastard1 points3y ago
In my case, probably, yes. I don’t like having to have everything twice. That’s why I record the episodes myself. That makes it easier for me, to synchronize it with the original audio from the DVDs.
ukifrit1 points3y ago
it isn't that bad for content in English, but for Portuguese stuff you won't find much stuff with AD.
DrillInstructorJan1 points3y ago
One of the things that really pisses me off about AD is that you can watch a show on one service, and it has AD. Then you go watch it on another service, and it doesn't. Somehow it doesn't carry over. And then you watch a show in one place (say the USA) and go back to the UK and they've done the AD again even though it would be totally fine to just use the American one. That's a stupid duplication of effort in a situation where we all just want as many things done as possible.
rp-turtle1 points3y ago
I think there could definitely be more work done on providing audio description. I don’t watch any live broadcasts except on YouTube so I can’t speak to that. The streaming services are doing a pretty good job of audio describing all of their original content with Netflix doing the best by far. I do not think there’s enough audio description for pre-recorded content. Even shows that end up on Netflix from other companies do not always come with audio description. I mean, until everything provides audio descriptive, there will still be more work to do imo.
bradley221 points3y ago
I’m not a huge tv person but there’s quite a lot of audio description in the Uk.
There’s also audiovault.net
RJHand1 points3y ago
Audiovault's kind of illegal though lol. But I guess it is still an option. Netflix has quite a lot of AD content, seems almost all of it has it, in Canada at least. Very rarely do I come across anything that doesn't.
bradley222 points3y ago
It is but I don’t care :)
RJHand1 points3y ago
Yeah I mean its not a very large group using it, considering how few blind people there are, and also given that its just audio of movies the downloads are therefore smaller and draw less attention to anyone looking to crack down on things like that.
Our mission is to provide everyone with access to large- scale community websites for the good of humanity. Without ads, without tracking, without greed.