Bring your karma
Join the waitlist today
HUMBLECAT.ORG

Blind and Visually Impaired Community

Full History - 2021 - 04 - 22 - ID#mwbo0k
5
Audio Description survey and review request (self.Blind)
submitted by morbidSuplex
Hi all!

Since my thread regarding audio ducking in audio described movies(https://www.reddit.com/r/Blind/comments/msvuph/ideas_to_fix_severely_ducking_audio_description/), I got very interested in your comments regarding audio description quality and mixing. I would like to request something, if you guys don't mind. I am very new to audio description, so I am interested in what more experienced people think about it. Who knows, I may have been too picky ...

* can anyone review the audio quality of this episode? I personally think it is a little bad due to extreme ducking when the narrator speaks, but I would like to here from someone who has listen to more audio descriptive movies. What do you all think about the mixing of this episode? https://www.dropbox.com/sh/t6zfirfhl2lljdh/AAAoFIi_3h5s8o4dMIHgy9SCa/Season%208?dl=0&preview=08+-+02++Homeland+-+Catch+and+release.mp3&subfolder_nav_tracking=1
* Can anyone name a movie that you believe have horrible audio description quality? For example, the movie track is extremely low while the narrator is speaking? I'd like to do an audio comparison of such movies.

Thanks all!
MilkbottleF 4 points 2y ago
* I'll anser your second question first because it's the easiest. Look into the audio descriptions from Amazon Prime where they use their new system with automatic ducking and text-to-speech instead of real live humans to read (High Life, Under the Silver Lake, Sleeping Dogs Lie, Dazed and Confused, House of Demons, Coppola's adaptation of the Outsiders, Vivarium, Skin, It's a Wonderful Life). The uncredited description scripts are surprisingly competent;they don't give you the comprehensive detail or the graceful prose of a DVS/Deluxe/IDC script, but they get the job done (if the exact same words were being read out by Hannah Brownlie or Georgina Rose instead of RoboNarrator [F US] I would have few complaints). And you can get used to the TTS, after a while it just fades into the background. But the mixing can be fucking ghastly (depending on the volume of the movie itself), they almost mute the audio every time the describer "speaks" so that you strain to hear the actual film sounds. Since it is automatic and indescriminate (amazon has insured that these descriptions can be churned out as fast n' cheap as possible by removing virtually all human involvement), it doesn't matter if you're watching a quiet musicless conversation at a restaurant table, or a Christopher Nolan shootout on a hill with a $1 it's all mercilessly cranked down to the same low volume.

* Though the ducking in your linked episode is undoubtedly too much for this narrator, it's not what I would call "extreme", yes the sound is lowered, but it is still clearly audible. A year ago I saw an eightyeight-minute film with the same describer and didn't notice any audio problems (he also voices Green Room). Keep in mind, however, that I watch all movies with headphones so everything is crystal clear no matter what, speaker/television/home theatre users may have a different experience.
morbidSuplex [OP] 1 points 2y ago
"the mixing is fucking ghastly, they almost mute the audio every time the describer "speaks" so that you strain to hear the actual film sounds."

​

I wish I could here this kind of description. Do you know anywhere I can listen to these online?

​

"Though the ducking in your linked episode is undoubtedly too much for this narrator, it's not what I would call "extreme", yes the sound is lowered, but it is still clearly audible."

​

Ah, so I am right after all, I have been too nitpicky. Funny thing is, I enjoyed watching this show a year ago. When I heard another movie that doesn't lower the volume that much I began complaining about this particular show.

​

I too enjoyed this describer. I like how he describes things.

​

Anyway thanks for your comment!
Old-Set-829 2 points 2y ago
The audio quality is perfect. Continue
morbidSuplex [OP] 1 points 2y ago
I don't understand. What do you mean by "continue"?
This nonprofit website is run by volunteers.
Please contribute if you can. Thank you!
Our mission is to provide everyone with access to large-
scale community websites for the good of humanity.
Without ads, without tracking, without greed.
©2023 HumbleCat Inc   •   HumbleCat is a 501(c)3 nonprofit based in Michigan, USA.