If there was a 100% safe procedure, would you have it if it would give full 20/20 vision?(self.Blind)
submitted by BlindRyan1
My buddy and I are having a discussion and I'm curious what the blind community thinks. It doesn't erase the past. All it does is give you full working vision with no side effects (in this hypothetical.)
I'd vote Yes even if there was a 1% success chance, but only as long as failure meant death.
HeftyCryptographer214 points2y ago
I feel like pointing out that I am Deafblind and I picked yes for this question but if it was asking about hearing , I wouldn’t have.
BlindRyan1 [OP]1 points2y ago
Why? I'm curious. Isn't one fundamental limitation as bad as the other? I don't mean that to be insulting. I mean not being able to hear is limiting just as not being able to see is limiting. How much is irrelevant. Both things do limit a person.
HeftyCryptographer213 points2y ago
I think it is just the way I grew up. I like being Deaf, and I am used to it. I haven't been blind very long. Plus, hearing people alwas seem very unhappy to be hearing. they are always grumpy about something they heard, or a noise that is bothering them. I don't have that.
BlindRyan1 [OP]1 points2y ago
Ah, I understand. You went deaf first. That makes more sense.
[deleted]3 points2y ago
Absolutely!!! In a heart beat! Yeah I’ve made great friends because of my vision but to be able to live independently and do everything independently!!! Ugh!!!! Maybe in my next life I’ll have 20/20!!
CosmicBunny973 points2y ago
No. I’ve never had perfect vision and don’t care much to have it.
Tarnagona3 points2y ago
No. Would I like some improvements? Yes. Less eye strain, and light sensitivity. Definitely. And I’d love the freedom of driving (waiting til I can have my own self-driving car).
But no, I don’t think I’d want instant 20/20 vision. For one, having been low vision my entire life, I don’t think my brain could cope. But even if it could, I’m happy with my life as it is, I know how things work, what I can do and what I can’t, and I feel like I’m already living my best life. Why fix what isn’t broken?
retrolental_morose3 points2y ago
Interestingly I would have said no as a child and teen. Having become a parent I'd have to completely change my answer.
CloudyBeep1 points2y ago
Why the change?
retrolental_morose6 points2y ago
I've just found there are things that would be so much easier with even a little vision with children. Public transit, busy environments, even school playgrounds. Learning how to write, understanding more about colour. So much detail work, really. But even having enough sight to identify a bus stop if we are a little off because of something else where the canework is unfamiliar would be a huge improvement.
I'm not saying a totally blind parent is ineffective of course, I'd like to think I manage pretty well!
[deleted]1 points2y ago
[deleted]
browneye542 points2y ago
Absolutely
grinchnight142 points2y ago
I wouldn't. Being born blind means I'll have to learn things like writing and stuff. And not to mention driving, yuck. No thank you.
Best_Equal_32202 points2y ago
I see no downsides here
BlindRyan1 [OP]1 points2y ago
I knew someone was gonna make that joke. Love it!
Best_Equal_32201 points2y ago
Oh, that was unintentional lol
BlindRyan1 [OP]1 points2y ago
Blind puns are an integral part of the culture. :P
[deleted]2 points2y ago
[deleted]
BlindRyan1 [OP]2 points2y ago
I have been. It's not. My identity is intangible. My skin color, heritage, sexuality, and disabilities only flavor it. I am more than the sum of my parts. I am especially not a single part.
grinchnight141 points2y ago
Exactly. Being blind isn't even a way I'd describe myself. It's just a thing, it's not part of my personality
[deleted]1 points2y ago
[deleted]
Winnmark2 points2y ago
Hell yeah.
casserole_cat1 points2y ago
I voted yes but only because I’m legally blind and hard of hearing. Now I love the deaf community and even though that’s extremely difficult I wouldn’t change it. But with my vision I would. Because for my hearing personally there are hearing aids that would “fix” it. (I don’t own any because my parents can’t afford them but also won’t do anything to get me into any kind of program)
With my vision I just can’t make good of it I don’t know anything I like about it. The community is small and I have never met anyone like me in person I know that’s not saying much because I’m only 16. But yes I feel alone and it’s scary not seeing good. And it’s frustrating. Teachers plop me in the front row and expect that to fix it but I have to say that I still can’t see the board and they say that it’s not their problem basically and then I have to figure it out for myself.
People don’t understand vision loss they don’t understand what I can and can’t see. But with my hearing they can more they still forget and talk too quietly but it’s easier to understand and make accommodations for.
I hope one day my answer will change because this is a hypothetical and I just have to live with my reality. But yep I wish I was fully sighted.
autistictechgirl19901 points2y ago
No I’m used to it Iv had my visual impairment all my life
Timely-Fruit1 points2y ago
Absolutely! Wholeheartedly! I wouldn't mind relearning, I wouldn't mind not having perfect vision. Ideally more than my perfect, as clear as can be, light and shadow perception. Partial vision appreciated, enough vision to get a driving license preferred. I can't be more limited than I am now, so anything but this.
bradley221 points2y ago
I can’t vote but I’d say yes.
snow6711 points2y ago
Yes. Anyway, how are you guys voting in Bacon Reader? It says I need to be logged in, but I already am.
[deleted]1 points2y ago
[deleted]
MaplePaws1 points2y ago
My vision shenanigans as I have taken to calling them I would for sure take it, my vision is actually still around that 20/20 but between the light sensitivity and my brain not controlling my eyes properly that vision is more to my detriment than help. I would even take it if it meant removing my vision altogether because these shenanigans have resulted in more dangerous situations than I can count. At the very least with less vision I start to qualify for things like O&M training, though I am still fighting for it because of the aforementioned dangerous situations my vision causes.
Our mission is to provide everyone with access to large- scale community websites for the good of humanity. Without ads, without tracking, without greed.