Hi all, I can’t believe I hadn’t thought of this before I went to a few other people. Especially since visually impaired folk I imagine are some of the top users of this accessibility tech.
My boyfriend and I are both sighted, but recently he discovered the dictation feature on his laptop. This revolutionized things for him— as he suffers from chronic pain in his hands/arms, as well as simply finding communication easier as an autistic person without having to text it.
Problem is, he also struggles with OCD which manifests in paranoia and delusions. One of the most prevalent for the past several years have been surveillance-based. The idea that someone is listening or watching him through his personal devices.
Obviously, there’s a bit of a difficult balance to strike here. If he wants to use dictation, he’ll have to reckon with the fact that his computer will, quite literally be “always listening to him”. Validating the delusion in ways not done before.
We both think that a good solution to this (before he’s able to hopefully work past it in therapy, of course) is a dictation machine that connects outside of the computer. So that it can be unplugged or turned off when not in use. We’re particularly interested in ones that work with Mac OS, since that’s the computer we both have. But his is pretty old at this point, so if a Microsoft OS is better, we can switch.
Someone on another sub recommended the Phillips Speechmic, it seems good. But very expensive for us poor, soon-to-be university students. Products over 250$ aren’t out of the question if they’re an honest good investment in his comfort. But I thought I’d ask here last in case anyone has any really good, cheaper suggestions.
retrolental_morose9 points1y ago
Sorry, off-topic, but why the hell do sighted people constantly assume we can't type? I don't mind educating people at all. But the sighted are also able to learn to *touch*-type. We do, too. yet, we're blind, we *must* dictate. I get it at least once a week.
why, please?
DHamlinMusic2 points1y ago
This. Exactly this. Fyi this was typed on my phone.
TechnicalPragmatist1 points1y ago
Yes exactly. It’s like I can type. Typing isn’t the issue. It’s screen reading. So they invented text to speech hahaha! It’s not so much being able to type or not it’s more about our eyes don’t work so we can’t see the screen.
Thedeaddrsunshine [OP]1 points1y ago
Apologies, it wasn’t that. He also uses it to press tabs on his computer and do other things than typing as I gather it.
retrolental_morose1 points1y ago
I hope you find something that works out - I wasn't meaning to have a go at you particularly ... just the stereotype which is far too common
CloudsOfMagellan4 points1y ago
Just have him enable it when he wants to use it and disable it when he wants to stop
CloudyBeep3 points1y ago
I don't really understand what you want the "dictation machine" to be able to do.
BenandGracie3 points1y ago
Do they even make dedicated dictation machines any more? I personally hate dictating to a computer or phone, so I usually just type. Dragon Dictation might be an option.
yoyo27182 points1y ago
Most computer dictation programs have a start and stop button, so it doesn’t have to constantly listen. Not sure if that helps or not. Only other thing I can think of is maybe a voice recorder or something. Some of them I think can be combined with software to transcribe to text, though I’m not sure how accurately, or what program is used. Dragon is the best speech to text computer program I know of, maybe look into it, either alone or in combo with a voice recorder? Honestly I’m just guessing here though. Maybe get in touch with an adaptive technology expert.
TechnicalPragmatist1 points1y ago
Such a hardware doesn’t really exist outside of just external microphones.
Tarnagona1 points1y ago
Depending on the computer, you could use any mic, and just unplug it when not in use, assuming your computer doesn't have an inbuilt microphone (laptops tend to, but desktops generally don't).
Dragon is, as far as I know, still the best speech-to-text program out there. Not sure if it has a Mac version, though. And I don't know what other kind of features it has beyond writing text into a document, like operating menus or programs with your voice.
Point of note, many blind people will use dictation on phones or other touchscreen devices, as it can be faster than navigating a touchscreen with a screen reader (and I don't think they use anything special, just what's built in to Siri). But this sounds like the opposite of what you're looking for. A phone has a microphone built in, that, while you can choose not to use it, you can't actually unplug or disable it. Every blind person I know touch types at a computer (it's called \*touch\* typing for a reason, after all). My one friend who uses Dragon regularly is fully sighted. You might have better luck asking communities of people with dyslexia or other written language processing issues, as they may have more suggestions.
bradley221 points1y ago
If he has an Iphone/android device he could use that. You can speak to the phone and it will write what he says.
You do have to say the punctuation though; for example: hi comma, how are you questionmark?
Our mission is to provide everyone with access to large- scale community websites for the good of humanity. Without ads, without tracking, without greed.