Bring your karma
Join the waitlist today
HUMBLECAT.ORG

Blind and Visually Impaired Community

Full History - 2022 - 02 - 24 - ID#t06ulu
0
Accessibility of Social Media (self.Blind)
submitted by Tiltedstillplaying
Hello everyone,
I’m tasked to do an accessibility analysis of a social media post and chose Instagram. I’m wondering how blind people use instagram and wanted to ask you for your experience. I chose to analyse a post by Molly Burke. If you use Instagram, can you please share your experience with me?
Emmenias 5 points 1y ago
Not sure why of all the social media available, you decided to choose the one whose main aim is the sharing of images ... of course some blind people use it, but you are bound to have a harder time than if you picked almost anything else.

How about not focusing on giant companies with so many controversies that there is a Wikipedia article for those alone, and it lags when loading? I know it is the cool and trendy thing not to care about one's privacy — and given that I gave in and joined Reddit, I can hardly judge — but Facebook is an evil of its own.

Have you heard of Mastodon? Not as popular, perhaps, but there is a reason why a small blind community has developed on it (mainly on DragonsCave.space, but also elsewhere); it is incredibly accessible out of the box, with other frontends like Pinafore for those that want them, accessible apps for both major mobile operating system, and more image descriptions than anywhere else by far. And it is a part of a large network of social media that can all communicate between each other, called the Fediverse, which includes alternatives to YouTube (PeerTube), music streaming services (Funkwhale), and even Instagram, if you want something similar (Pixelfed)

No pressure; do whatever is easiest/most interesting for you. But I bet your analysis would be incredibly cool if you thought out of the box. :)
bradley22 3 points 1y ago
I’ve not heard of this but I’m a big YouTube user, is peertube any good? what kind of things are on there?
Tiltedstillplaying [OP] 3 points 1y ago
Yeah that’s very interesting to hear, but I think analyzing the major social media platform is necessary.
We do this in a uni course called accessible web.
Emmenias 3 points 1y ago
Why does its size mean it is more necessary to analyse it? It is still a platform for sharing images; the main pressure to make it accessible rests on the users, who need to write alt text. And even with that in mind, there is only so much a blind (rather than visually impaired) person could get from it.
Is it not more necessary to point out better, accessible alternatives, as well as ones that both do not track you and frankly have a much kinder community, of actual people rather than politicians, companies, and influencers.
Tiltedstillplaying [OP] 0 points 1y ago
I didn’t say it was more necessary haha I just meant that our topic we were given is “analyzing a social media post”. And it has to be scientifically based as well. Tbf the scientific research concerning app usage isn’t so advanced that’s why I opted to ask here :)
[deleted] 2 points 1y ago
[deleted]
EyesR4Nerds 2 points 1y ago
Hey, maybe I’m reading your tone or intentions wrong, so please correct me if that’s the case.

I don’t necessarily disagree with your point, but I’m also cautious about being hostile towards people with an interest in learning more. Education is our friend, rather than putting someone with good intentions down for trying.

Again, apologies if I misunderstood.
Emmenias 3 points 1y ago
That is a valid concern. I perhaps could've been more gentle in my delivery. I can be overly passionate when promoting stuff I love.

But in my defense, I was not trying to descourage them from the project, and instead trying to bring to their attention an alternative social network that would be more interesting to research than the usual contendors. And you gotta admit that Instagram is not the easiest choice to work with regarding blind accessibility; even if its interface were perfect, most of us would not have any real desire to use it regularly (as other replies in this topic confirm).
EyesR4Nerds 1 points 1y ago
No worries, your point is valid! Passion is important for positive momentum.
DariusA92 5 points 1y ago
I rarely use Instagram. Probably the most useful accessibility feature of Instagram is the alt text field. When you are posting a picture describe it in there. The text won't be shown, but the screen reader can read it. And if you post a video, if there is important text in there, like a URL, phone number, opening and closing time and the like, and a narrator doesn't read it, add that text to the post, because we won't have access to it.
akrazyho 3 points 1y ago
The app is very accessible but the content just isn’t. Of course your exception sues rule depending on the content it decide to follow but the majority of it has content that has no descriptions to what you’re watching or seeing.
Marconius 3 points 1y ago
Instagram is a very one-way experience for me. I post things every now and then, but never actually scroll through the main feed. My only uptick in its use came with Clubhouse, since Instagram and Twitter were the primary ways you'd be able to communicate with people from Clubhouse before they made their own private messaging system. I also have Instagram tied into dating apps like OkCupid and Tinder, giving a more accessible picture uploading experience than those apps actually offer.

I hate that I can't just switch the Instagram usernames to actual names since I always forget who is who on that platform. Even with the alt text additions to the platform, people hardly use it and it's just a slog trying to navigate the app with VoiceOver.
Sad_Wheel3435 1 points 1y ago
A short answer. The Instagram is not fully accessible.
rumster 1 points 1y ago
Because of our Discord event this week - OP didn't see the weekly thread. We will let this one hold and thank you to whoever reported I didn't even notice this post this morning.
This nonprofit website is run by volunteers.
Please contribute if you can. Thank you!
Our mission is to provide everyone with access to large-
scale community websites for the good of humanity.
Without ads, without tracking, without greed.
©2023 HumbleCat Inc   •   HumbleCat is a 501(c)3 nonprofit based in Michigan, USA.