I've been working at Starbucks for two years and today's the first day a guest (that's what we're forced to call customers at Target) broke a cup. My coworker told the guest she'd need to pay for it. When she and her friends got to the register, I was on register and my too-nice ass blurted out, "Oh, that's not your fault." It was one of those Christmas ornaments made out of ceramic. It's one with our state on it. We display them with their box open, and they sit neatly in the box but if you tip the box, the ornament's coming out. So after I mentioned that, the guest's friend went, "It's not her fault but she's gotta pay for it?!" I was like, "Uh... I don't know. Honestly, this has never happened before." "What's your store's protocol for it?" "I don't know." (I've only worked at Target for a month and no one's mentioned any policy regarding guests breaking stuff.) So my coworker starts chiming in, and this conversation isn't getting anywhere. I've said way too much by trying to be polite to the idiots who can't pick up a cup without breaking it. I mention to my coworker that we can ask a team leader what to do. She says they'll probably just say the guest doesn't have to pay for it. Long story short, the cup didn't get paid for. Point of the story: does anyone know if Starbucks and/or Target has a policy regarding this?
QuietCity33321 points1y ago
i’ve never seen any big chain *actually* have a “you break it you buy it” policy. having a good customer experience is usually more beneficial to the company than the profit from the broken item.
philosopher_cat_lady [OP]2 points1y ago
That makes a lot of sense. Target can afford to lose an item of merchandise.
Apprehensive_Flow21914 points1y ago
the product can be marked out as damaged
echowolf94 points1y ago
As an ex supervisor, definitely wouldn’t charge them. I would just mark it out as damaged in IMS. Charging them doesn’t really fit with Starbucks’ image they pretend to uphold.
philosopher_cat_lady [OP]1 points1y ago
It was my opinion that they shouldn't be charged, but my coworker likes to be hard on guests and is a very headstrong person as well.
tellovisions4 points1y ago
I don’t see why they should if it was an oopsy
philosopher_cat_lady [OP]1 points1y ago
What's the difference between that and spilling your drink? I also argued with coworkers before over that one.
Former-Highway-66653 points1y ago
Not a target or starbucks but I dropped and shattered a mug I was about to pay for in self checkout at a large chain grocery store and they came and told me to just get another one and that I wouldn’t have to pay for the one I broke so I’d assume because it’s a target it’s the same kind of thing
philosopher_cat_lady [OP]2 points1y ago
Right. I would imagine customers breaking merchandise doesn't happen often, so the grocery store doesn't mind losing that profit.
lewabwee3 points1y ago
I can’t speak for target but Starbucks absolutely doesn’t have a “you break it you buy it” policy. If people throw their drinks on the ground we remake them for free, even if the drink is the price of a cup.
philosopher_cat_lady [OP]2 points1y ago
This is what I thought: Starbucks (which I'm assuming my workplace would qualify as) wants guests to leave satisfied and we're supposed to make the moment right. So if a guest spills their drink, we're supposed to remake it for them for free. That happened the other day to me, a child spilled her drink. I remade it and her mother asked if she needed to pay for it. I said no. At a company-operated Starbucks store I worked at, one of my shift supervisors didn't want to remake a customer's spilled drink for free. Here's the thing about that, I think it's kind of a depends-on-the-situation decision. As a customer, I would WANT to pay for the broken cup or spilled drink, as I'm the one who did it. Shit happens, of course, but we're talking about $10 here. It's not the end of the world to purchase the merchandise you broke. It's just that Starbucks honestly coddles their customers. We're supposed to remake drinks if you \*don't like them\*.
596259622 points1y ago
I had a guest (target) bump into our cup display with ilhis motorized scooter breaking like 4 of our cups. No, they don't have to pay for them
philosopher_cat_lady [OP]1 points1y ago
Thanks for mentioning this to me!
Texastexastexas12 points1y ago
I don't think the buyer is an idiot.
Whoever removed the ceramic object from it's package must know that it might fall and break when someone picks it up -- that is the idiot.
philosopher_cat_lady [OP]1 points1y ago
Yeah, honestly, I'm probably being too hard on the guest. My coworker was very adamant in her belief that the guest should pay for what she had broken. Then the guests who were in line after her were very adamant in the same view. The other day another guest dropped one of the same kind of ornament, but it didn't break. People don't realize that the mug is not attached in any way to its box.
Texastexastexas13 points1y ago
That's why it should stay in the protective box. Now you have a patrern of this happening. Solve the problem.
Our mission is to provide everyone with access to large- scale community websites for the good of humanity. Without ads, without tracking, without greed.