favorite "surprise me" drink to make?(self.starbucksbaristas)
submitted by CatalyticGenesis
i am asking this as a barista lmao, i need ideas
my go-to lately has been brown sugar +1 cinn dolce pump with the dolce topping. it works for lattes, cold brew, frapps, and even with black iced tea so it's a big winner.
for tea/refreshers i usually do lemonade with raspberry and top it with passion tea to get that gradient look (it's so pretty, i love making it).
i like to switch it up though and give customers a variety of drinks (tho i stay away from fucking obnoxious drinks, the goal is fun flavor combos not "oh i am going to commit a crime upon witnessing this drink"). we also do a 'drink of the week' thing so we always need new drinks.
what's everyone's go-to when customers ask for a surprise, and do you have any unusual favorites to do with it?
Sageiscat347 points11m ago
Grande Ice Water
LyricallyChallenged33 points11m ago
Personally I'd suggest a tall 😂
lilkiosk17 points11m ago
With no ice
highspeed0613 points11m ago
no just grande. just the cup
Perfect_Potted_Plant6 points11m ago
This
SelocAvrap5 points11m ago
I always gave them a "Due to the possibility of allergies and the chance you might not like something, I'm not able to surprise you, but I'm happy to help you find a drink you'd like. Would you like something hot, iced, or blended, and is there a drink you usually get that you like?"
Chole62413 points11m ago
Sensational
Snarfungus129 points11m ago
had a group of middle school aged girls come into my old location and ask for 5 surprise me drinks. they were pretty rude, and the barista on pos rang them up for 5 tall pike coffees
urlessies22 points11m ago
w barista
CyzophyTacos73312 points11m ago
Its what you get for being rude.
honeybeebi58 points11m ago
raspberry lemonade w/ a splash of passion tea on top to make that pretty ombré. always has gotten me tips and very happy customers, sweet and tasty too for the summer. :)
happysloth412 points11m ago
Very underrated drink since so many people hate the passion tea. Whenever I want something other than coffee I get a passion tea lemonade but extra lemonade and either peach juice or raspberry syrup depending on the mood I’m in lol. It’s tart and refreshing and actually feels worth $5
Swimming-Fee-24454 points11m ago
Isn’t this known as the Sunset drink?
StormTheParade8 points11m ago
Memory is turbo-foggy but I thought the sunset drink used the old Tea Infusions, no?
BatWeary6 points11m ago
i think that one is the same drink they mentioned in the comment, but strawberry instead of passion. both versions are pretty popular + look almost identical lol
honeybeebi1 points11m ago
idk just something i saw on tiktok
JunipherStar56 points11m ago
Iced caramel apple spice with vanilla sweet cream cold foam
gingergal-n-dog24 points11m ago
Why have I never thought to make this drunk iced?? Maybe I'll try it with salted foam tho
gabby246815 points11m ago
I’ve tried it with salted foam hot and it was very good but I know that’s blasphemous
JunipherStar5 points11m ago
It’s so good! The system won’t ring it in as iced though.
TheBDudgeon12 points11m ago
Grande cold juice, add ice, add CD syrup, add VSCCF, add CR drizzle would be the “correct” way to ring it in. But honestly, skip the drizzle and add dolce topping, much better that way.
JunipherStar1 points11m ago
The drizzle helps make the drink I think, but thanks for the tip on ringing it in :)
forgetmenaughts52 points11m ago
I do the snickerdoodle! Half cinnamon dolce half white mocha, whip and cd topping. My old SM said it was his go to for surprise mes and now it’s mine lol
Danielitics041 points11m ago
Bruh I'ma have to try this
mulberrybby1 points11m ago
Same
ellensaige16 points11m ago
a blonde ristretto espresso (however many shots they want) with toffee nut and sweet cream! it's so tasty and my go to on my break or after work, and people have liked it so far
AmumuLoL5 points11m ago
Been doing this recipe as an undertow for my breaks. Takes no time to make prior to hopping off bar.
ExcitementClassic72814 points11m ago
If we are busy, it's a nitro, a iced chai, or a vanilla cream cold brew. Sorry it's basic but....peak....
If we are not so busy I go with a iced chai with oatmilk and a shot of espresso. Maybe brown sugar, maybe cold foam.
Pink drink with matcha cold foam
Salted caramel cream cold brew with dark caramel instead of caramel syrup.
sero507411 points11m ago
“Tiramisu Cocoa” i created this when i worked there. basically it’s a dressed up iced mocha. here’s my recipe. i always did venti. a lot of my partners begged me to make it and to share the recipe but i never did but since i no longer am claimed by the siren you can have the recipe.
2 Blonde ristretto shots
2 pumps mocha
2 pumps vanilla
1/2 scoop of cocoa powder
oatmilk
1/2 scoop cocoa powder in cold foam
pour the cold foam on top, sprinkle cocoa on top and mocha drizzle
🤪
edit format
Broad-Flounder-497110 points11m ago
Depends on what they want, but I would do something simple because they always ask this during peak. Surprise! It’s a pike 😂
imtotallysurebro9 points11m ago
If I’m feeling extra nice a horchata almondmilk Frappuccino, otherwise a mango dragonfruit or strawberry açaí with green tea instead of water.
Edit: I don’t call the frappucino by name to customers as it’s discontinued or off the menu or whatever and that would cause issues a la secret menu.
gingergal-n-dog3 points11m ago
What is the horchata recipe? It's before my time.
imtotallysurebro13 points11m ago
It’s a coffee based Frappuccino made with almondmilk and cinnamon dolce syrup. Gets caramel drizzle and cinnamon dolce sprinkles on top. So good.
BatWeary6 points11m ago
around valentine’s day i’ll do a cold brew with white mocha and sweet cream or an iced white mocha and top whichever they prefer with strawberry foam, and the peppermint mocha topping (chocolate curls) if we still have some.
any other time i’ll do a cookies and cream cold brew (same recipe as above, just with vsc foam blended w cookie crumbles instead of strawberry!) unless they want something hot. then they get a salted caramel mocha (just without the salt bc the packets don’t work at good :( )
if it’s a kid, it depends on if they’re allowed caffeine. no caffeine i’ll do strawberry frap with chocolate drizzle, vanilla bean with mocha OR toffee nut, passion tea lemonade with raspberry, or blended strawberry (purée—not açaí) lemonade with raspberry. if caffeine is okay i’ll do a refresher with raspberry or peach. or a flavored hot chocolate:) typically i’ll give them white mocha, cinnamon dolce and cd sprinkles!
Afta-math116 points11m ago
Toffee nut latte with a pump of white mocha
Purgatory-Maybe5 points11m ago
Iced chai with brown sugar (usual amount of pumps for both), it tastes like gingerbread! :))
OneRoseDark5 points11m ago
iced oatmilk latte with brown sugar and dark caramel.
ProfessionalRock79405 points11m ago
If they ever ask for a surprise me drink I just make them the basic bitch white mocha
black-cat1044 points11m ago
My fav “surprise me” and recommendation lately has been passion tea lemonade sweetened and with one pump of raspberry! To me it tastes like a popsicle and it’s been a hit especially since we’ve been having the rolling shortages of strawberry/mango refreshers
CapsizedZebra3 points11m ago
I give people a pink drink w no inclusions and no ice and remove the sticker. They think it’s milk and then spit take when they drink it 😂
MoistMenu41313 points11m ago
Vanilla bean frap w mango dragon fruit pieces, salted Carmel cold brew with dark farm in the foam, or a pink drink with matcha foam
darkwolf5233 points11m ago
Nitro
FlowerCurious5813 points11m ago
Passion tea lemonade at strawberry base
Environmental-Mail402 points11m ago
I would rather the customer know what they want do the cost of any “surprise me” drink. A few times at our location we have had customers ask for a “surprise me” drink only to complain about the cost. 😢 Now I do brewed coffee with a shot or an under toe! Secretly, I want to just give them a glass a faucet water. SURPRISE!! 🤓 Wonder how they order at restaurants??🤔🤔
aniyahstarr2 points11m ago
Water
emmalllemma2 points11m ago
For tea I would always do the peach green tea lemonade but add raspberry as my shift drink, or black tea with milk and brown sugar If they like matcha, adding brown sugar is very good Sometimes people would flavor the cold foams with syrup or powder
PartyAnything34082 points11m ago
iced matcha latte- made with heavy cream or sweet cream. add vanilla (skip if used sweet cream). 1-vb scoop. shaken with cinnamon inside. add sccf if you’re feeling frisky
daughterhood2 points11m ago
Matcha lemonade w splash of pineapple base but people look at me like a monster
CatalyticGenesis [OP]1 points11m ago
lmao as if almost the same thing didn't used to be an official drink. my memory is fuzzy but im pretty sure pinapple ginger matcha lemonade was in fact, an on-menu drink. (either that or just the pineapple matcha latte was on-menu)
gingergal-n-dog2 points11m ago
Black and white mocha
Salted caramel mocha (mocha & toffee nut)
Caramel apple spice
Breve misto
White mocha cookie crumble
SAR no water, sub apple juice
Matcha lemonade
Toffee nut iced latte upside down with mocha drizzly
zydr8te4 points11m ago
Will add Java chip white mocha (cream base). Tastes like an oreo
fluidrienne171 points11m ago
I usually do the pineapple refresher with lemonade with raspberry and dragon fruit pieces🤷🏽♀️
Nraveles111 points11m ago
Pink drink with raspberry and cold foam if they want a more refreshing drink
Nitro with sweet cream and cinnamon dolce if they want coffee
Comfortable-Plane9441 points11m ago
You guys get enough surprise me drinks to worry about this
ElijahLordoftheWoods1 points11m ago
Venti iced chai
Wild-Pie72281 points11m ago
grande passion tea lemonade w 3 agave
MamaRedCard1 points11m ago
Iced coffee with double the size appropriate pumps of hazelnut and a dash of halfnhalf
Wes-Anderson141 points11m ago
Passion tea with no water, peach juice, and toasted vanilla
morningchampagne1 points11m ago
My surprise really depends on the season. As it’s almost fall but still hot. I would do an apple pie frap. Cream base, whole milk with apple juice, 1 pump caramel and 1 pump cin dolce. Top with caramel and cin dolce sprinkles.
HamiltonPolka1 points11m ago
Flat white with white mocha
New_Consequence_51841 points11m ago
White mocha with raspberry and blonde shots! It used to be my go to drink, and now I use it on customers.
alexkerie1 points11m ago
i personally call it an horchata, but it’s a black tea with sweet cream instead of water, vanilla and cinn dolce with cinnamon powder shaken in. tastes real close to actual horchata
ScroogeMcDust1 points11m ago
I call it Drinkenstein's Monster.
It's a Mango Dragonfruit Refresher with no water, no inclusions.
Add Passion Tango, peach juice, 2 pumps raspberry syrup, one pump peppermint, and top it off with VSCCF.
It's not exactly popular with whoever is on bar, but it has this gorgeous ruby hue and tastes delicious
tacosubterfuge1 points11m ago
White mocha frap with brown sugar, cinnamon blended in and crunch topping... better if made with oatmilk imo.
DaWitcherr1 points11m ago
Venti shaken espresso - Sub 3 pumps white mocha - sub breve (or oatmilk) - add cinnamon powder - (salted foam if you’re feeling wild)
This was my go-to back when we still had the starbucks double shot lol
CitrusFriend3991 points11m ago
For espresso, usually an iced white mocha with toffee nut and salted caramel cold foam :)
For a frap, strawberry's and cream with white mocha or mocha cookie crumble sub mocha for dark caramel
Refresher, mango dragon fruit refresher, no water, no incl, sub water for peach and half pumps of vanilla
[deleted]1 points11m ago
[deleted]
Tdawwg781 points11m ago
Venti iced oat latte with toffee nut syrup
[deleted]1 points11m ago
[deleted]
almondmiilktea1 points11m ago
VSCCB with 1 pump white mocha, VSC Foam & CDL topping !!
Our mission is to provide everyone with access to large- scale community websites for the good of humanity. Without ads, without tracking, without greed.