a nice lotion (unscented or lightly scented) would be a good idea, given how winter and sanitizer ruin everyone's hands.

custom nametags if you're particularly artsy?

sharpies if your store doesnt provide them

cute pins and fun/festive socks would be cute!

Sharpies and box cutters 🥰

stress balls

chapstick, lotion and a small candle!

I would appreciate good pens/permanent markers, pins, candy/snacks, and fidgets/stress balls

All of these suggestions are great tbh, and to add to the custom name tag suggestion, I would say even just block form lettering with a white outline on the tops of all the letters to look like snow would be cute (pro tip, you can use clear nail polish to make them permanent)

always love those colored sharpies

Fuzzy socks and candles are always a win

My old SM gifted everyone gloves

I made custom pins for my store for the holidays! I can definitely help u out as well if u want :)